Ally Kelley

Ally Kelley

Global Real Estate Advisor

Born and raised in St. Petersburg, Florida as a fifth generation Floridian, Ally graduated from the University of South Florida, then moved to the Florida Keys in 2016 after earning her Real Estate License. She quickly became one of the top producing agents and in 2017 was recognized as the Marathon and Lower Keys Association of Realtors' "Rookie of the Year". Since then, she has successfully closed over $60 million in sales (even honorably selling Big Pine Key's highest sale twice), earned Ocean Sotheby's "Female Top Producer", served as the MLKAR President (2022), President-Elect (2021), Treasurer (2020, 2019), Board Member (2017, 2018), and voted as Marathon's "Best Realtor" in 2021.

Her passions include her two goldendoodles, working out, boating, and sunsets. She also stays heavily involved in the Middle Keys community, serving as a member of the Marathon Chamber of Commerce, Rotary Club of Marathon, Leadership Monroe Class XXVIII, and on the Baptist Health Fisherman's Foundation Board. 

She lives and works behind the mentality that luxury is an experience, not just a price point. Her mission is to offer a "white glove experience" and exemplary results to every client while showcasing her love for the Florida Keys community, knowledge of the real estate market, and passion for exceeding expectations.

Meet Ally Kelley | A Personal Introduction Video 

Contact Us

Featured Listings


1 Man O War Drive

Glittering oceanfront views, meticulous attention to detail and modern architecture define this island oasis located in Marathon. Nestled at the end of Man-O-War Drive, new 2019 CBS, 3-story hom...

2600 Overseas Highway Unit: 25

Picturesque paradise found at Tranquility Bay Beach Resort in Marathon, TripAdvisor's winner of the 2021 Traveler's Choice Award. Discover the luxury of on-site resort management, income producing ...

982 Ocotillo Lane

Buildable, spacious 11,690 square foot non-waterfront lot located in one of Marathon's beloved neighborhoods, Flamingo Island, near Sombrero Beach. This lot does NOT convey with a building permit. ...

Sold Listings


29550 W Cahill Court, Big Pine Key FL

Introducing ''Contemporary Keys Haven'', the epitome of a secure Florida Keys estate for divers, boaters, and sunset-lovers positioned behind a custom gated entry. This breathtaking oceanfront comp...

111 Coco Plum Drive, Marathon FL

Rare turn-key beachfront property with a 100 ft pier dock offers traditional coastal architecture with unobstructed open water views for a one of a kind, impeccable Keys estate. The private drive l...

2919 Sombrero Boulevard

Debuting Marathon's Mermaid Manor to the market, coveted waterfront Sombrero Golf Course location with 125 ft of new concrete seawall, 15,000 lb boat lift, dinghy davit, and two 50-amp shore power ...

11240 3rd Avenue Gulf

Casually and coastally elegant, this Gulfside garden cottage is perfectly nestled on an 8,485 sf lot with three bedrooms, three bathrooms, 1,656 sf living area, one-car garage, and 77 ft concrete s...

201 Sombrero Boulevard, Marathon FL

Owned by two of Marathon's Pioneers, spacious property located on protected Boot Key Harbor and Sombrero Golf Course: BEST of both worlds. Enjoy beautiful open water views and deepwater dockage. Ea...

240 10th Street

Distinctly coveted Key Colony Beach location, East facing stilted waterfront half duplex featuring two-bedrooms, two-bathrooms, nearly 1,300 square feet inside, and 37.5 ft concrete seawall with st...

Work With Us

Whether you are buying or selling your home, you can trust Ocean Sotheby's International Realty to provide a superior level of professional real estate services that exceed your expectations.

Contact Us